Players to have represented the Camberwell Magpies Cricket Club in the First XI since the Collingwood CC & Camberwell CC merger.
- RD Taylor
- CA Ingram
- RD French
- CL Francis
- DR Shanahan
- PA Broster
- DA Emerson *
- SJ Smith
- MTG Elliott
- GR Vimpani
- AJ Amalfi
- CJ Harris
- AS Blackwell
- SA Cann
- SS Young
- NC Petricola
- M Sutherland
- M Dollman
- RR Dodds
- DJ Davies
- SW Clark
- LH Devlin
- DJ Aston
- RJ Wignall
- TW Mawdsley
- TD Arendarcikas
- AC Englezos
- BS Shadbolt
- AD Jones
- MD White
- NJ Walker
- AD Kellett
- C Tippett
- SR Pietersz
- CM Trewin
- MJ Lancaster
- WJ Elliott *
- BA Knowles
- KJ Neville
- MJ Cox
- JG Weinstock
- ML Hewat
- LM Baldry
- A Parry-Okeden
- NA Broster
- CA Binney
- PQ Harper *
- GDF Hope
- AP Lasky
- SF Hill
- AJ Hardy
- TD Evans
- MT Rafter
- * DT Beardsley
- MR Hutton
- JC Pearson
- JP McNamara
- BI Righetti
- NP Hutton
- MW Dwyer
- MR Hayward
- AJ Stewart-Holmes
- SJ Gribble
- WS De Kretser
- RX Hassett
- J Moss
- BM Hanley
- SSN Parker
- GS Parker *
- NMB Smiljanic
- JA Cross
- MS Wade
- JP Bray
- AP Maynard
- TL Ryan
- DB Hutton
- JM Roberts
- JGD Dowling
- JA Joslin *
- ST Atkinson
- WG Shute
- BAC Howell
- TC Leoncelli
- TB Rickarby
- JT O’Connell
- JC Lampard
- JG Martignago
- ANF Potter
- A Michener
- MS Grose
- CM Thewlis
- AE Brown
- BJ Doyle
- AL Fekete
- MD McClean
- BK Watkins
- PJ McKenna *
- RJ Chancellor
- SD Snell
- JR Bett *
- JL Crosthwaite
- WG Walker
- TV Russ *
- NS Richardson
- CJ Austin
- MG Berryman
- BG Drew
- AW McDermott
- SG O’Brien
- AR Stanley
- LR Mahon
- AJ Doolan #
- AF de S Eldridge *
- MA Persson-Clark
- MJ Whittaker
- JM Bird #
- BT Rowles
- DJ Rawson
- JM Martin
- SS Singh
- JP Murphy
- S Bhargave
- XJ Doherty #
- CW Bridle
- SC Mays
- DP Hodge
- KA Prior
- A Pawha
- SPJ Newell
- BJ Webster #
- JW Wiseman
- OR Gunning
- JRH Rosewarne
- LD McManus
- KJ Jamieson
- IW Conway
- AG Kodoth
- AK Smith
- RM Guddadamane
- OJ Jenkins
- HJ Burrill
- W Townsend
- LD Fitzpatrick
- BL Jowett
- B Shields
- T Nelson
- J Di Stefano
- R Jamieson
- A Vidajic
- S Wood
- D Redhu
- C Fitzsimmons
- A Gorvin
- K Walford
- C Hinchcliffe
- W Mazza
- S Challa
- G McComb
- A Deshpande
- C Edmonstone
- T Scott
- S Bhaiya
- S Chopra
- J Lyndon
- H Walsh
- A Ridley
- A Nair
- S Paramesh
- K Herft
- C Simondson
- P Paramesh
- P Dooley
- J Fraser
- P Forrest
- J Pietz
- H McKenzie
- T Pearson
* = Former player with one or more of the club's under-age teams in the ESCA or ECA
# = Guest BBL player when T20 games were part of the annual Victorian Premier Cricket fixture
BOLD = Current CMCC player
